ACCC appeal against CFMEU and Hutchinson boycott judgment dismissed

Source: Australian Ministers for Regional Development

The majority of the High Court has today dismissed an appeal by the ACCC against a decision of the Full Federal Court in proceedings against the Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union (CFMEU) and construction company J Hutchinson Pty Ltd (Hutchinson).

The High Court ruling upholds an earlier appeal by the CFMEU and Hutchinson against a Federal Court finding that they had reached an anti-competitive boycott arrangement or understanding.

The ACCC had alleged, and the Federal Court trial judge in the original judgment had found, that the CFMEU and Hutchinson made an arrangement or understanding to boycott a waterproofing subcontractor at the Brisbane Southpoint A apartments construction site in 2016, meaning the subcontractor could no longer perform the work.

“We took this case originally because boycotts are a kind of anti-competitive conduct which harms the economy as well as individual businesses and consumers,” ACCC Chair Gina Cass-Gottlieb said.

The ACCC’s appeal sought the High Court’s ruling on what is required to demonstrate that parties have reached an anti-competitive arrangement or understanding.

“We took this appeal because the issue of what is needed to prove an arrangement or understanding is an important one for the enforcement of our competition laws,” Ms Cass-Gottlieb said. 

“The ACCC respects today’s High Court ruling. It reflects the complexity of enforcing these provisions of our competition laws.”

“We remain committed to enforcing our laws and holding those who engage in anti-competitive conduct accountable,” Ms Cass-Gottlieb said.

Background

Hutchinson is one of Australia’s largest privately owned construction companies.

The Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union is a trade union organisation that represents members in a number of industries including the construction industry. When proceedings started it was known as the ‘CFMMEU’, while today it is known as the ‘CFMEU’.

Sections 45E and 45EA of the Competition and Consumer Act prohibit contracts, arrangements or understandings that contain a provision included for the purpose of preventing or hindering the acquisition of goods or services from a supplier, which is also referred to as a “secondary boycott”.

On 4 December 2020, the ACCC instituted proceedings against Hutchinson and the CFMEU.

On 14 February 2022, the Federal Court found that by making and acting on the agreement, Hutchinson contravened sections 45E and 45EA of the Competition and Consumer Act.

The CFMEU was found to have been knowingly concerned in, or party to, the contraventions by Hutchinson.

The Court also found that the CFMEU induced Hutchinson’s contraventions by threatening or implying that there would be conflict with, or industrial action by, the CFMEU if Hutchinson did not stop using the particular subcontractor.

On 30 August 2022, the Federal Court ordered the CFMEU and Hutchinson to pay penalties of $750,000 and $600,000 respectively.

On 29 February 2024, the Full Federal Court upheld appeals by the CFMEU and Hutchinson against the first-instance decision.

On 2 April 2024, the ACCC sought special leave to appeal to the High Court from the Full Federal Court’s judgment that upheld appeals by the CFMEU and Hutchinson. Leave was granted in August 2024, and the appeal was heard in December 2024.

Police working with City of Hobart and local businesses to reduce retail crime

Source: New South Wales Community and Justice

Police working with City of Hobart and local businesses to reduce retail crime

Wednesday, 2 April 2025 – 12:38 pm.

More than 100 people attended a retail crime and safety forum in Hobart this morning to discuss strategies for making stores and shopping precincts safer.
Inspector John Toohey said the event, organised by Tasmania Police and City of Hobart, brought together community leaders, police and retailers.
“Today’s forum highlights the importance of working together to reduce crime,” he said.
“By collaborating, we can create better strategies to target retail crime and make our environment safer for everyone.”
“There are simple things retailers can do to prevent crime, from ensuring the store layout allows visibility to installing high-quality CCTV and other security measures.”
“Properly training staff, engaging closely with customers and restricting access to key areas is also key.”
“If a crime does occur, it’s important the matter is reported to police in a timely manner so our officers can respond effectively and hold offenders to account.”
“We want our local businesses, and communities more broadly, to be able to thrive without worrying about crime.”
“It’s crucial that both the public and employees feel safe not only in public spaces but also in their workplaces.”
City of Hobart Lord Mayor Anna Reynolds said the council is dedicated to creating a safe and vibrant retail environment in Hobart.
“Today’s discussions have reinforced the need for ongoing collaboration between the council, law enforcement, and retailers to address the challenges we face,” she said.
Retailer Warren Lucas said retail crime not only affects businesses’ bottom line, but also the safety and wellbeing of staff and customers.
“Forums like this are essential for sharing knowledge and developing practical solutions to these issues.”
The forum provided a space for meaningful conversations and idea-sharing, paving the way for stronger partnerships and better strategies to fight retail crime.

Second person charged in relation to murder at Glenorchy

Source: New South Wales Community and Justice

Second person charged in relation to murder at Glenorchy

Wednesday, 2 April 2025 – 12:32 pm.

Police have charged a second person with murder following an incident at Dickson Street, Glenorchy, on 11 March, which resulted in the death of a 19-year-old man.
The 15-year-old youth was arrested last night. 
They have been detained to appear before the Youth Justice Court today. 

Police investigate damage at Stanley penguin viewing platform

Source: New South Wales Community and Justice

Police investigate damage at Stanley penguin viewing platform

Wednesday, 2 April 2025 – 12:26 pm.

Police are investigating after a series of incidents where damage was caused at the Godfreys Beach Penguin Viewing Platform at Stanley.
Between Tuesday 18 March and Saturday 22 March, several LED strip lights and guide lights were damaged or removed from the platform off Harrison Terrace. 
The marine-grade lighting had been fitted over information boards, and around the platform.
Police are also investigating similar incidents of damage at the platform in recent months.
Anyone with information about these incidents should contact Smithton Police on 131 444 and quote Offence Report 770206.

First Nations bush tucker inspires creative works

Source: New South Wales Ministerial News

As Australia’s first UNESCO Creative City and region of Gastronomy, the latest Djaa Djuwima celebrates First Nations bush tucker through a range of traditional and contemporary creative works.

The exhibition Dhelk Djakitj, which means nourishing food in Dja Dja Wurrung language, is inspired by bush tucker – the food, the people, Country and stories that bring them together.

This is the first exhibition for newly appointed Djaa Djuwima Curator and Arts Officer First Nations Michellie Charvat.

Twelve talented artists are exhibiting their work in Dhelk Djakitj following a recent visit to the Me-Mandook Galk education place in Chewton where the bush tucker farm Nalderun is located.

Ms Charvat said she was delighted to be involved at the start of the creative process with exhibitors.

“It was a wonderful visit to Me-Mandook Galk education place which inspired the artists in so many different ways,” Ms Charvat said.

“The artists had the opportunity to learn about the bush tucker that Nalderun is growing and harvesting, to ask questions and gain a great deal of inspiration from the farm and surrounding area on Dja Dja Wurrung Country.

“They then developed their artworks to reflect their diverse experience, personal connections to bush tucker through traditional and contemporary art forms such as painting on canvas, digital art printed, creating coolamons out of traditional and natural fibres or contemporary craft forms such as beading.

“The free exhibition is a brilliant display of artworks exploring bush tucker and the personal connections to food and culture,” Ms Charvat said.

“It is also a wonderful collaboration, celebrating the region’s designation as Australia’s first Creative City of Gastronomy at Djaa Djuwima.

“Djaa Djuwima is important in the spirit of reconciliation because it offers the opportunity for visitors and local residents to experience the diverse local First Nations peoples and artists’ exploration of their own culture and identity through their art forms. Djaa Djuwima means to show and share Country and was established on Dja Dja Wurrung Country in 2022.”

The community is welcome to attend the opening of Dhelk Djakitj tomorrow, Thursday April 3 from 5pm to 6.30pm at Djaa Djuwima.

The free exhibition is open until September 2025. Djaa Djuwima is located in the Bendigo Visitor Centre, Pall Mall and is open 9am to 4.30pm daily (except Christmas Day).

Police seize 12 kilograms of cannabis during separate searches

Source: New South Wales Community and Justice

Police seize 12 kilograms of cannabis during separate searches

Wednesday, 2 April 2025 – 12:13 pm.

Two people have been charged after police seized more than 12 kilograms of cannabis during three separate searches at George Town.
George Town Police conducted the searches between 28 March and 31 March.
A 50-year-old George Town man was arrested following one search, and has been charged with multiple drug-related offences, including trafficking in a controlled substance.
A 51-year-old George Town was searched twice within three days, and allegedly found in possession of large quantities of cannabis on both occasions.
He has been charged with multiple drug related offences including possess a controlled plant product, possess a controlled drug and trafficking in a controlled substance. 
Both men, who are not linked, will appear in the Launceston Magistrates Court at a later date.
Anyone with information about illicit substances is asked to contact police on 131 444 or Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000 or at crimestopperstas.com.au. Information can be provided anonymously.

Police officer charged

Source: New South Wales Community and Justice

Police officer charged

Wednesday, 2 April 2025 – 11:59 am.

A 28-year-old Constable from Southern District is due to appear in the Hobart Magistrates Court on 8 August 2025, having today been served with a summons to appear on two charges of common assault.
The offences are alleged to have been committed in Hobart on 19 November 2024.
The officer was on duty at the time of the incident. He has been placed on non-operational duties.
It is not appropriate to make any further comment given the matter is now before the court.

Business

Source:

Following the introduction of the public CBC reporting regime in Australia, the ATO is committed to ensuring clear and effective guidance on its administration.

One key component of this regime is the exemption process, which allows certain entities to apply for full or partial exemptions from public reporting requirements under specific circumstances.

To support the fair and transparent administration of exemptions, we are developing a draft Practice Statement (PSLA) to outline the criteria, evidence requirements, and decision-making framework. The PSLA will outline the Commissioner of Taxation’s approach to proposed public CBC reporting exemptions in the Treasury Laws Amendment (Responsible Buy Now Pay Later and Other Measures) Bill 2024. The guidance will include:

  • the process for submitting applications
  • information that should be provided with applications
  • considerations relevant to the exercise of the discretion sought.

This initiative builds on feedback received during the consultation process for the drafting of the public CBC reporting and aims to provide clarity and certainty to affected multinational entities (MNEs).

2024 Completed matters

Source:

[202424] Tax agent supporting compromised clients using Strong online access strength pilot

[202422] Foreign resident capital gains withholding

[202421] Personal financial advice fees paid by superannuation funds – claiming deductions and PAYG withholding obligations

[202420] Retirement villages web guidance

[202419] Optimising the objection process for individuals

[202417] Reducing paper activity statements

[202416] Local File/Master File (LCMSF) Schema Version 4.0 short form local file instructions

[202415] GST product classification – self-review guide and checklist

[202414] Tax consequences on sales of small-scale land subdivisions

[202413] Additional tier 1 capital note issuances

[202412] Supplementary annual GST returns for Top 100 and Top 1,000 public and multinational business taxpayers

[202411] Advance pricing arrangement program review recommendations

[202410] Statement of account usage and delivery preference

[202409] Attribution of risk weighted assets for thin capitalisation (foreign banks)

[202408] Inbound related party financing by private groups in the property and construction industry

[202407] Delivering Better Financial Outcomes (Quality of Advice) – Recommendation 7

[202406] Administration of deceased estates

[202405] Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles – valuing fuel

[202403] Embedding value-added macro data into natural digital systems

[202401] Multinational Tax Integrity – strengthening Australia’s interest limitation (thin capitalisation) rules

[202424] Tax agent supporting compromised clients using Strong online access strength pilot

Consultation purpose

To understand how the ATO can support agents to promote the benefits and adoption of a Strong online access strength (OAS) to compromised individuals within their practice client list.

Description

Encouraging compromised taxpayers to adopt a Strong OAS has the benefits of restoring real-time access to digital services and pre-fill access for registered agents. It facilitates easy access to taxpayers’ superannuation, personal details and ATO mail via their myGov Inbox. The Strong OAS pilot, which commenced in July 2024, aims to leverage the trusted agent-client relationship and the support of registered agents to promote the benefits of OAS to their clients.

Who we consulted

Outcome of consultation

Insights and observations from the pilot were used to draft 4 recommendations which will help encourage the adoption of Strong OAS and provide a better experience for agents with compromised clients. The recommendations will be referred to relevant ATO business areas for consideration in future continuous improvement programs.

Consultation lead

Scott Bradford, Frontline Business Improvement
Scott.Bradord@ato.gov.au

[202422] Foreign resident capital gains withholding

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on proposed changes to foreign resident capital gains withholding (FRCGW) website guidance to ensure the content is clear, relevant, and meets stakeholders’ needs.

Description

The FRCGW regime in Australia requires Australian residents to obtain a clearance certificate from the ATO to avoid having 12.5% of the sale price withheld on property sales of $750,000 or more. Foreign residents have 12.5% withheld, which is paid to the ATO by the purchaser. Without a clearance certificate, Australian residents are treated as foreign residents, and the withholding applies.

Legislative changes to the FRCGW regime were announced in Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook 2023–24 and will come into effect from 1 January 2025. The key changes include:

  • increasing the withholding rate from 12.5% to 15%
  • removing the $750,000 withholding threshold
  • applying the changes to relevant capital gains tax assets.

These changes are expected to significantly increase the number of clearance certificate applications.

We are updating our website guidance on the FRCGW to reflect the upcoming legislative changes. We are seeking feedback from law and conveyancing professional associations to ensure the proposed content is clear, relevant, and meets stakeholders’ needs.

Who we consulted

  • Law and conveyancing professional associations

Outcome of consultation

Feedback from targeted consultation on the proposed changes to FRCGW website guidance was invaluable in assisting the ATO to shape and improve our guidance material, ensuring the content is understood and meets stakeholder’s needs.

We provided draft content of the proposed changes and received feedback from stakeholders. This will be incorporated into the content under development, which will be updated in due course.

As part of the consultation, a number of other matters were raised by law and conveyancing professional associations. These will be addressed separately.

Consultation lead

Louie Markovski, Superannuation and Employee Obligations
Louie.Markovski@ato.gov.au

[202421] Personal financial advice fees paid by superannuation funds – claiming deductions and PAYG withholding obligations

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on the proposed draft Practical Compliance Guideline from superannuation industry representatives prior to the publication of the draft for public consultation.

Description

Following the outcome from earlier consultation [202407] Delivering Better Financial Outcomes (Quality of Advice) – Recommendation  7, the ATO is developing a Practical Compliance Guideline to provide superannuation funds with a compliance approach in relation to the amendments made to the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 1997) under Schedule 1 of the Treasury Laws Amendment (Delivering Better Financial Outcomes and Other Measures) Act 2024 (the Act).

The amendments under Schedule 1 of the Act provide a legal basis for payment of advice fees from a member’s superannuation account and clarify the associated tax consequences.

The ATO is seeking feedback on our proposed compliance approach for:

  • working out the income tax deduction under item 5 of the table in subsection 295-490(1) of the ITAA 1997
  • historical PAYG withholding obligations under paragraph 307-10(e) of the ITAA 1997.

Feedback from superannuation industry representatives will assist to refine and enhance the guidance before the draft is published for public consultation.

Who we consulted

  • Industry representatives
  • Professional associations
  • Superannuation funds
  • Tax professionals
  • Relevant government agencies
    • Australian Securities and Investments Commission
    • Australian Prudential Regulation Authority

Outcome of consultation

Feedback received from the consultation provided valuable insights on the impact of the proposed compliance approach to superannuation funds. These insights will be considered in developing our compliance approach under this draft Practical Compliance Guideline.

Consultation lead

Jay Gao, Public Groups
Jay.Gao@ato.gov.au

[202420] Retirement villages web guidance

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on proposed website guidance that focuses on informing operators about key tax implications throughout the retirement village lifecycle.

Description

We are seeking to publish web-based content that consolidates existing guidance which identifies tax issues, income tax and GST at each stage of a retirement village lifecycle. This web guidance does not introduce new views and is not intended to cover tax technicalities related to retirement villages. It aims to make taxpayers aware of their income tax and GST obligations using a lifecycle approach.

Who we consulted

Outcome of consultation

Minimal feedback was received. Where appropriate, feedback was incorporated into the website guidance.

Consultation lead

Rosie Cicchitti, Private Wealth
Rosie.Cicchitti@ato.gov.au

[202419] Optimising the objection process for individuals

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on a prototype digital objection process that has been designed to replace the current paper objection process for individuals.

Description

For individuals to lodge an objection with the ATO, they currently need to download, fill out, and return post or fax a paper form. The ATO digital strategy outlines an aspiration to be fully digital by 2030. To meet this challenge, we are consulting with community members and tax agents to understand their views on a prototype digital objection process that has been designed to replace the current paper objection process for individuals.

Feedback will ensure the design of the prototype digital objection process meets the needs of stakeholders and will assist to identify any areas for improvement.

Who we consulted

  • Individuals

Outcome of consultation

User research has been considered in the development of digital objections prototypes. Further consultation may take place on prototype iterations in the future.

Consultation lead

Dejan Markov, Enterprise Strategy and Design
Dejan.Markov@ato.gov.au

[202417] Reducing paper activity statements

Consultation purpose

To understand what drives preferences for the retention of paper activity statements and the blockers to transitioning to digital channels.

Description

The ATO digital strategy outlines an aspiration to be fully digital by 2030. To meet this challenge, the ATO is looking to consult with agents around the current and future use of paper activity statements and understand the impediments that may exist to a continued transition towards digital lodgment.

Who we consulted

  • Professional associations
  • Tax agents

Outcome of consultation

Feedback will be used to identify ‘pain points’ in the transition from paper to digital and will guide the development of proposals intended to drive increased digital lodgments and assess the potential impacts on agents.

Consultation lead

Steve Windeyer, Frontline Business Improvement
Steve.Windeyer@ato.gov.au

[202416] Local File/Master File (LCMSF) Schema Version 4.0 short form local file instructions

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on the instructions supporting Local File/Master File (LCMSF) Schema, Version 4.0, and the updated requirements which incorporate short form local file reporting.

Description

From 1 January 2025, country-by-country reporting entities will use an updated version of the LCMSF service for lodgments, for reporting periods starting on or after 1 January 2024. LCMSF Schema Version 4.0 will incorporate the short form section of the local file into the Message Structure Table.

The ATO will seek feedback on updated Version 4.0 short form local file reporting, including what further clarification or examples may be provided in the reporting instructions. Consultation will ensure the instructions and updated requirements meet the needs of stakeholders involved in the reporting process.

Who we consulted

  • Large corporations and multinationals
  • Tax agents and advisory firms
  • Industry bodies
  • Digital service providers 

Outcome of consultation

Feedback received from consultation provided valuable insights and suggestions for potential improvements or clarifications to the Local File/Master File Schema Version 4.0 and instructions.

As a result of feedback, immediate changes were made to the Message Structure Table design. Feedback on other issues is being considered and is expected to result in changes to the instructions which are in the process of being finalised.

Consultation lead

Emily Worthing, Public Groups
LCMSFversion4@ato.gov.au

[202415] GST product classification – self-review guide and checklist

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on the new self-review guide and checklist for GST classification of products to ensure it meets the needs of taxpayers.

Description

The ATO has developed a self-review guide and checklist for GST classification of products. The self-review guide and checklist is designed to provide taxpayers with practical step-by-step guidance to:

  • undertake regular self-review of the GST classification of their supplies
  • assess the robustness of business system processes and controls that directly impact the decisions on GST classification of supplies.

Feedback will ensure the self-review guide and checklist meets the needs of taxpayers and will help to identify any areas for improvement.

Who we consulted

  • Industry representatives
  • Advisory firms
  • Members of the GST Stewardship Group

Outcome of consultation

Feedback provided some valuable insights which will be incorporated into the self-review guide and checklist for GST classification of products to improve the documents and ensure they meet the needs of taxpayers. The self-review guide and checklist for GST classification of products are available on the Legal database.

Consultation lead

Virginia Hernandez, Public Groups
Virginia.Hernandez@ato.gov.au

[202414] Tax consequences on sales of small-scale land subdivisions

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on proposed additional examples of tax consequences on sales of land, including small-scale land subdivisions.

Description

The ATO is seeking to expand on the published Tax consequences on sales of small-scale land subdivisions by adding to the examples currently on our Legal database.

The proposed expansion will centre around 3 current topical areas:

  • properties acquired or held for multiple purposes, including resale for profit
  • the circumstances which constitute mere realisation of a capital asset
  • carrying on a business of renovating properties, also referred to as ‘property flipping’.

Who we consulted

  • Private Groups Stewardship Group
  • Communication Content Working Group
  • Property and Construction Stakeholder Relationship Forum

Outcome of consultation

Feedback was generally positive. Stakeholders found the draft web guidance examples helpful and recommended minor amendments to improve the examples’ effectiveness. Feedback is being considered for inclusion in the updated web guidance.

Consultation lead

Andrew Fenn, Private Wealth
Andrew.Fenn@ato.gov.au

[202413] Additional tier 1 capital note issuances

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback to inform potential public advice and guidance on additional tier 1 (AT1) capital note issuances.

Description

AT1 capital is a key element of the capital structure for Australian financial institutions. The ATO receives numerous applications for binding advice through the rulings system on the tax consequences associated with AT1 capital notes for investors and issuers.

There is currently a high level of maturity and consistency in AT1 capital note issuances, including their terms and features and their tax consequences.

The current approach to providing guidance is on a case-by-case basis. The ATO is considering opportunities to streamline guidance on AT1 capital note issuances and is seeking feedback on whether a Taxation Ruling would eliminate or substantially reduce the incidence of class and private ruling requests.

Who we consulted

  • Financial Institutions
  • Industry bodies
  • Tax agents and advisory firms

Outcome of consultation

The feedback received provided perspective on the key issues that stakeholders view as requiring consideration in respect of public advice and guidance in relation to AT1 capital note issuances.

On 10 September 2024, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) issued a Media Release announcing a proposal for banks to phase out the use of AT1 capital instruments. In light of this announcement, the ATO will place the project regarding potential public advice and guidance on AT1 capital note issuances on hold, pending the outcome of APRA’s proposal.

Consultation lead

Veronica Richards, Public Groups
Veronica.Richards@ato.gov.au

[202412] Supplementary annual GST returns for Top 100 and Top 1,000 public and multinational business taxpayers

Consultation purpose

To understand what guidance is required to assist taxpayers with completion of the supplementary annual GST return.

Description

In 2024–25, the ATO is introducing a new supplementary annual reporting requirement for Top 100 and Top 1,000 taxpayers who have received a GST assurance rating through an earlier GST review.

The introduction of the return will enable us to make informed decisions about future engagements with taxpayers and enhance our treatment strategies and ability to monitor GST risks that arise in the large market.

Who we consulted

Outcome of consultation

Targeted consultation provided valuable feedback which is being considered and will be incorporated in the design and implementation of the supplementary annual GST return. For more information about the return, see Supplementary annual GST return.

Consultation lead

Virginia Gogan, Public Groups
Virginia.Gogan@ato.gov.au

[202411] Advance pricing arrangement program review recommendations

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on the 8 recommendations made from the advance pricing arrangement (APA) program review and consider their appropriateness and if additional changes are required to the APA program.

Description

Targeted consultation is required to assess the current state of the advance pricing arrangement program to determine if additional changes need to be implemented following the report recommendations from the APA program review that was completed 30 June 2023.

Who we consulted

  • Big 4 accounting firms
  • Law firm Minter Ellison

Outcome of consultation

Feedback received from the consultations was invaluable in providing the ATO with a better understanding of the market perceptions of the APA Program, including:

  • identifying key issues and areas for improvement from stakeholders in the APA Program, particularly following the implementation of the APA review recommendations
  • gathering suggested improvements for the APA Program
  • providing an indication of how well the ATO is communicating with taxpayers and tax professionals.

The suggestions are being workshopped with internal stakeholders with a view to identifying which proposals can be implemented. Once internal decision-making is complete, these insights will be considered in the updates to the revised APA Practice Statement Law Advice.

Consultation lead

Gloria Cassimats, Public Groups
Gloria.Cassimatis@ato.gov.au

[202410] Statement of account usage and delivery preference

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on the frequency, usefulness, and preferred delivery channel of the ATO statement of account.

Description

The ATO issues statements of account for a variety of reasons using different correspondence channels (paper and electronic) and is reviewing options to reduce the frequency of automated statements of account.

The ATO is consulting with taxpayers and their representatives to obtain feedback on:

  • the current frequency, usefulness, and delivery method of automated statements of account
  • proposed options to reduce the number of automated statements of account issued.

Who we consulted

  • Individual taxpayers
  • Small business representatives
  • Tax agents
  • BAS agents

Outcome of consultation

Feedback confirmed a preference for:

  • a reduction in the frequency of statements of account
  • electronic delivery channels.

These insights will be considered in the scoping and design of enhancements to the statement of account.

Consultation lead

Peter Moore, Strategy and Support
Peter.Moore@ato.gov.au

[202409] Attribution of risk weighted assets for thin capitalisation (foreign banks)

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on the ATO’s proposed view on the appropriate attribution of risk weighted assets to branches for the purposes of applying the thin capitalisation rules for inward investing entities (ADI).

Description

Foreign banks that conduct their banking business in Australia through branch(es) are subject to Australia’s thin capitalisation rules. The rules require a foreign bank to allocate a minimum amount of equity capital to its branch.

Typically, foreign banks use the safe harbour rule to work out their minimum capital amount. The rule is based on ensuring there is sufficient equity capital funding that part of the risk-weighted assets of the bank that is attributable to its branch.

The ATO does not currently have a published view on how to determine that part of the risk-weighted assets attributable to a branch. Feedback will assist in the development of an ATO view on the topic with the aim of providing certainty and a consistent industry approach.

Who we consulted

  • Foreign banks with branch operations in Australia
  • Industry bodies
  • Australian Banking Association
  • Australian Financial Markets Association
  • Tax agents and advisory firms

Outcome of consultation

Feedback received on the Discussion paper Thin capitalisation – attribution of risk weighted assets to Australian branches of foreign banks, which closed on 31 May 2024, is being considered for incorporation into the development of a draft Practical Compliance Guideline.

Consultation lead

Johanna Tang, Public Groups
Johanna.Tang@ato.gov.au

[202408] Inbound related party financing by private groups in the property and construction industry

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on proposed website guidance and examples relating to inbound related party financing by private groups in the property and construction industry.

Description

The ATO is seeking to publish website guidance relating to inbound related party financing by private groups in the property and construction industry including examples of financing arrangements.

Who we consulted

Outcome of consultation

Feedback received has been considered and discussed with consultation participants. As a result, the website guidance has been updated to improve the intent and clarity of our public advice and guidance.

Consultation lead

Lynette Purcell, Private Wealth
Lynette.Purcell@ato.gov.au

[202407] Delivering Better Financial Outcomes (Quality of Advice) – Recommendation 7

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on public advice and guidance needs for the new measure addressing financial advice fees charged under section 99FA of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993.

Description

The government has announced its response to the December 2022 Final Report of the Quality of Advice ReviewExternal Link by releasing an exposure draft: Delivering Better Financial Outcomes Package – reducing red tape and other measures.

Relevantly, Recommendation 7 seeks to clarify the legal basis for superannuation trustees to charge individual members for financial advice from their superannuation account, as well as the associated tax consequences.

Division 2 of the exposure draft makes amendments to the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 to ensure that financial advice fees charged under section 99FA of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 are:

  • tax-deductible for the fund
  • not treated as superannuation benefits of the member.

Such fees are tax deductible to the fund to the extent that the amount charged to the member’s account was not incurred in relation to gaining or producing the fund’s exempt income or non-assessable non-exempt income. The measure is proposed to have retrospective effect.

The ATO is seeking feedback on whether there are priority issues where public advice and guidance is needed to help superannuation industry stakeholders understand how the new law applies to their circumstances.

Who we consulted

  • Professional associations
  • Superannuation industry representatives
  • Advisory firms

Outcome of consultation

Consultation provided valuable feedback which will be considered in the preparation of future public advice and guidance materials.

Consultation lead

Ernest Lui, Public Groups
Ernest.Lui@ato.gov.au

[202406] Administration of deceased estates

Consultation purpose

To seek feedback on the ATO’s administrative arrangements for accessing a deceased person’s information, particularly where a grant of probate or letters of administration has not been obtained.

Description

In July 2020, the Inspector-General of Taxation published the report Death and Taxes – An investigation into ATO Systems and Processes for dealing with Deceased EstatesExternal Link.

Recommendation 7(b) of the report recommends the ATO seek feedback on its administrative arrangements for accessing a deceased person’s information, particularly where executors or relatives have not obtained a grant of probate or letters of administration, to determine if the administrative arrangements are satisfactory to external stakeholders or if changes are required.

Who we consulted

  • Industry representatives
  • Relevant government agencies
  • Members of

Outcome of consultation

The consultation process identified several proposals for improvements to the administration of deceased estates and the legal framework that supports it.

The administration-related proposals are being workshopped with internal stakeholders with a view to identifying which proposed improvements can be implemented.

The suggestions for improvements that have law implications are being analysed to determine which are suitable for escalating to Treasury for their consideration.

Consultation lead

Lloyd Williams, Individuals and Intermediaries
Lloyd.Williams@ato.gov.au

[202405] Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles – valuing fuel

Consultation purpose

To explore possible valuation methodologies for both electricity and petrol expenses of a plug-in hybrid electric vehicle (PHEV).

Description

Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2024/2 Electric vehicle home charging rate – calculating electricity costs when a vehicle is charged at an employee’s or individual’s home provides a methodology for calculating electric vehicle home charging expenses. However, the guideline does not apply to PHEVs, which use a mix of fuels (electricity and petrol) to power the vehicle.

The ATO will consult with key tax and electric vehicle experts on whether there is a possible valuation methodology, that provides a reasonable basis to split the kilometres driven fuelled by electricity or petrol for a PHEV.

Who we consulted

Outcome of consultation

The purpose of the consultation was to engage subject matter experts and explore whether there is a possible methodology that provides a reasonable basis to split the kilometres driven fuelled by electricity or petrol for a PHEV.

The consultation has confirmed a possible method, which now requires updates to certain public advice and guidance (PAG) products. These updates have recently been noted by the ATO’s PAG Steering Committee (during October) and the ATO is now separately progressing the required updates, which will be consulted on prior to finalisation.

Consultation lead

Mark East, Superannuation and Employer Obligations
FBT@ato.gov.au

[202403] Embedding value-added macro data into natural digital systems

Consultation purpose

To understand how, and what types of, ATO macro data could be made available to small businesses to help improve their tax performance.

Description

Small businesses use third-party software, for example accounting software, to manage their business operations, understand and track their financial performance, and meet their tax obligations on time and in full.

The ATO is currently exploring the feasibility of embedding certain macro data and information into small business’ natural digital systems and software. This could include:

  • ATO or other government agencies’ benchmark data and benchmark tools
  • certain ATO risk rules.

This could assist small businesses and their advisers to:

  • identify and understand tax risks and potential processing errors
  • make informed decisions on identified tax risks
  • compare their financial performance to similar businesses
  • build confidence in the ATO’s administration of the tax system.

This is part of Improve small business tax performance, one of the key focus areas in the ATO corporate plan 2023–24. The ATO is collaborating with key stakeholders to build a digital-first tax ecosystem to enable small businesses to better understand their comparative tax performance and identify potential errors or tax risks prior to lodgment. This will help streamline the tax experience and make it easier for small businesses to comply with their obligations.

Who we consulted

  • Small businesses
  • Tax and BAS agents
  • Digital service providers
  • Financial technology providers
  • Tax professional partners
  • Small business industry representatives
  • Relevant government departments

Outcome of consultation

Feedback has helped the ATO to further understand:

  • the need to provide taxpayers with the opportunity to review and correct potential mistakes prior to lodgment
  • the need to provide more tax certainty at the right time, removing the need for ATO corrective actions where mistakes have been made
  • a potential way to reduce opportunistic or deliberate non-compliance.

The insights captured have supported the creation of a pre-lodgment check concept. This concept aims to provide information to taxpayers where their income tax or activity statement lodgment data does not match or meet ATO expectations. This provides the taxpayer an opportunity to review and correct the information (if necessary) before lodging. The ATO is considering the development of this concept.

Consultation lead

Michael Morton, Small Business
Michael.Morton@ato.gov.au

[202401] Multinational Tax Integrity – strengthening Australia’s interest limitation (thin capitalisation) rules

Consultation purpose

Following stakeholder feedback on PAG topics, prioritisation and form for the new thin capitalisation measures, we will now be consulting on the high priority topics to develop specific PAG products.

Description

On 8 April 2024, the Treasury Laws Amendment (Making Multinationals Pay their Fair Share – Integrity and Transparency) Act 2024 received Royal Assent.

The ATO is proposing to provide guidance setting out the Commissioner of Taxation’s views on, and approach to, key aspects of the proposed new thin capitalisation rules and debt deduction creation rules contained in Schedule 2 of the Act.

Stakeholder feedback is sought on potential topics, prioritisation and the form of any potential public advice and guidance.

It is intended that only the most important issues arising from the new law will be addressed through the preparation of early ATO public advice and guidance.

Who we consulted

Outcome of consultation

Targeted consultation provided valuable feedback which has assisted to identify and develop high priority draft public advice and guidance products. In May 2024, we published a list of guidance priorities regarding Amendments to the Thin Capitalisation rules – ATO’s PAG consultation topics and prioritisation. You can keep up to date through the Advice under development program.

Consultation lead

Stephen Dodshon, Public Groups
Stephen.Dodshon@ato.gov.au

Individuals

Source:

Description

The ATO has delivered an agent nomination process through the client-to-agent linking project to entities with an Australian business number (excluding sole traders). The next stage of the project is focussed on an authorisation process for individuals and sole traders to control who has access to their information through ATO online services. Consultation will include discussions with a variety of representatives including agents, professional associations, industry representatives, individuals and sole traders. This will assist us to make informed decisions on delivering this fraud control in the individuals market. The first stage of consultation involves targeted focus group sessions.